This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
Point of Begining Logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Point of Begining Logo
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Digital Edition
    • Classifieds
    • Subscribe
    • POB eNewsletter
  • Columns
    • GeoDataPoint Blog
    • Kline: Unmistakable Marks
    • Lucas: Traversing the Law
    • Solo Notes
    • Editor's Points
    • Turner: Surveyor's Footsteps
    • The Business Side
  • News
  • Products
  • Tech
    • GeoDataPoint
    • LiDAR/Laser Scanning/3D
    • Photogrammetry
    • GIS
    • GPS/GNSS
    • Hardware
    • UAS/UAV
    • Data Collection
    • Remote Sensing
    • Software
    • Total Stations
  • Industry
    • Aerial
    • BIM
    • Boundary & Topo
    • Construction
    • Energy & Utilities
    • Environmental
    • Forensics
    • Government
    • Marine/Hydrography
    • Mining
    • Transportation
  • Reports
    • Laser Scanning & 3D
    • Salary & Benefits
    • Surveying & Mapping Industry Software
    • Archives & Additional Reports
  • Education
    • Professional Knowledge
    • Continuing Education
    • GeoLearn
  • Online
    • Events
    • Webinars
    • Classifieds
    • POB Store
    • POB Point and Shoot
    • Photo Galleries
    • Videos
    • Polls
    • FARO Webinars
    • Industry Links
  • Directory
    • GeoLocator
  • Contact
    • Editorial Staff
    • Advertise
    • Clear Seas Research
    • Custom Content Marketing Services
    • List Rental
    • Store
  • POB Premium
Home » Guest Column: Hey, Don't Shoot The Teacher!
ColumnsGIS (Geographic information systems)Surveying BasicsGPS / GNSSSurveying Safety & Education

Guest Column: Hey, Don't Shoot The Teacher!

Education
January 29, 2016
Dr. Charles A. "Tony" Nettleman, III, PSM, Esq.
KEYWORDS Business challenges in surveying / future of surveying / survey technology basics / Surveying and mapping issues
Reprints
8 Comments

The bearing taken by Philip Adams in recent columns conveys his opinion that the biggest threat to the land surveying profession in decades is a trickle of highly educated but technically inept four-year graduates that thrive in calculus and physics, but could not find an iron pipe to save their lives. Nothing could be farther from the truth.

In this observation, I would like to rebut three of Mr. Adams’ key points:

  • Four-year graduates are expected to obtain a mix of education and experience to guide them through their professional careers
  • We are graduating more land surveyors every year, which could be substantially increased with the help of the profession
  • Heavily experienced but uneducated surveyors will redefine the term “terminal career path”

Adopting a plan where university degrees are marginalized and experience-based licensure is brought back once again will put land surveyors at a disadvantage with respect to civil engineers, architects and even lawyers, as well as create serious issues with technicians using sophisticated technology and depress the cost of our work (if lower cost is even possible).

It is true that eliminating the four-year degree requirement would allow us to greatly increase the number of Professional Land Surveyors in every state. But at what cost? Each state licenses land surveyors in part to protect the health, safety and welfare of the public. Allowing undereducated, “field-trained” technicians to become Professional Land Surveyors would defeat that goal. Even if these technicians were allowed to sit for the exams, it is unlikely they would ever to be able to pass them. The solution of Mr. Adams’ solution is to lower the test standards. Feel safe?

Over the past three decades, dozens of people including Gary Jeffress, Dave Gibson and Paul Wolf dedicated their entire careers to elevating the land surveying profession by creating several generations of well-educated, publicly-minded Professional Surveyors. Throughout that time, the profession has evolved from traditional cadastral surveying into a much more complicated vocation. Today, geomatics is a melting pot of cadastral surveying, remote sensing, unmanned aerial systems, GIS and many other sub-professions that require the practitioners to apply higher-level principles in mathematics and physics to deliver their work product. Without a strong education foundation, the profession would never have the expertise to undertake many of these new tasks.

The purpose of a college education is to provide the theoretical foundation for one’s entire career; it is not to practice turning angles or to be able to setup a tripod in less than 90 seconds. Geomatics educators spend four years instructing students how GPS tells us a location on the earth, how to compute measurement errors and then adjust for them, and the legal principles and ethical considerations that the public and government expect of our profession. These are the building blocks of a true professional; the need for students to learn practical skills has not fallen on deaf ears.

Working Together

Educators, at every level, have never voiced a notion that “you can’t replace experience without education.” In fact, we at Texas A&M-Corpus Christi conduct two field camps (technical instrument training and boundary location) each year, and students are required to take internships at least one summer while in the program. We host lunches and seminars from various businesses in order to place our students in internships and permanent employment.

Geomatics educators do not live in ivory towers. We understand the students must be well versed in the practical aspects of the profession. However, learning how to quickly set up a tripod or take a series of GPS measurements should be learned on the job after graduation, because there is simply not enough time to train both theoretical and practical aspects of geomatics in four years of university. The Texas Board knows this limitation, and that is why it requires two years of employment in responsible charge before allowed to sit for the RPLS.

The higher-education community shares Mr. Adams’ view that too few surveyors are graduating from our geomatics programs each year. The profession is turning gray and new blood is in high demand. Recruiting young people should not be the sole burden of the geomatics program, but should be shared between the universities, the state societies and the professionals in the field. Instead of suggesting we simply do away with all of the four-year programs, I propose that we reinvigorate the profession by creating a stronger relationship between these organizations.

At Texas A&M-Corpus Christi, we are working to properly prepare a new generation of geomatics professionals. We are working with community colleges to attract young people to community colleges, transfer their existing credit hours, and provide them a clear path to a four-year degree. On weekends, we host open houses where high school students can learn about the fascinating aspects of our profession and how becoming a Professional Land Surveyor will benefit them and provide a lifelong career. Within our own community, the professors attend almost every major land surveying and GIS event, such as the Esri user conference, National Society of Professional Surveyors annual conference and the Federation of International Geographers working weeks and bi-annual conferences. Professors at other geomatics programs are no less dedicated. Will you join us?

The frustration Mr. Adams expresses regarding the future of surveying and surveyors, to a great extent, is shared. I am of the opinion that a duty to the profession is to ensure quality education of members and future members. Recall the fundamental charge to protect the public safety and welfare. Lowering the professions standards, in this case standards of education, will not improve our situation in my view. In other arenas, unfortunately, we have witnessed many examples in our current society where standards have been lowered and now regretted.

The art and science of land surveying as reviewed above become more complex daily, and education to this writer is vital to our future. We need to attract future surveyors and educate them sufficiently in the technical sense and the practical field sense using high standards, not lower the bar. We will always have some degree of frustration with the product of our efforts, but let us not lower the bar only to genuinely regret it later.

The views of all, both educators and professionals, are appreciated. Working together, we can create a bright and prosperous future for the next generation of surveying professionals.

Subscribe to POB

Recent Articles by Dr. Charles A. "Tony" Nettleman, III, PSM, Esq.

Guest Column: How to Succeed on Surveying Exams

Tony Nettleman is a land surveying engineer who holds the distinguished position of assistant professor at Texas A&M Corpus Christi; teaches continuing education courses for attorneys and land surveyors; and serves as an expert witness in boundary, easement and title disputes. Nettleman graduated with honors at New Mexico State University with a Bachelor of Science in land surveying engineering, a Master of Science in geospatial engineering from Texas A&M Corpus Christi with honors, a PhD in geomatics at University of Florida, and a Juris Doctor at Florida International University. While attending various universities, he has worked with several multi-national engineering firms in addition to teaching classes at Troy University, Florida Atlantic University and University of Florida. Currently, Nettleman serves as an assistant professor of geomatics at Texas A&M Corpus Christi while lecturing for various profession groups and serving as an expert witness. He is licensed as a Florida attorney and a Florida professional surveyor. He can be contacted through www.CNettleman.net.

Related Articles

Guest Column: How to Succeed on Surveying Exams

Guest Column: Surveyor Offers Strong Ideas For The Profession

Guest Column: Less Education Is Not Surveying's Solution

Guest Column: A Two-Fisted Solution for Surveying

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscription Center
  • Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Renew
  • Create Account
  • Change Address
  • Pay My Bill
  • Free eNewsletters
  • Customer Care

More Videos

Popular Stories

SAM

SAM Acquires JMC Professional Surveying and Mapping, LLC

FAAlogo21Aug19News

Iris Automation and Kansas DOT BVLOS Drone Flight

Stonexnews4Dec19

Stonex Announces Camera Add-on

LeicaZenoPOBnews20Nov19

Leica Geosystems Enables GIS Data Capture

LeicaBLK3Dnewsletter27Nov19

Leica Geosystems Launches “BLK3D Web”

Poll

Surveyor Outreach Opportunities

What kind of community outreach do you perform on behalf of the survey/geospatial profession?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

POB Top 100 Report

POB Top 100 Report

We began by creating a survey as a cooperative effort between several high level geospatial leaders, POB staff, and Clear Seas Research market research experts. The survey was sent out to more than 25,000 geospatial professionals who subscribe to POB and/or are members of MAPPS.
See More Products

FARO webinar series

POB

POB December 2019 cover

2019 December

In the December 2019 issue of POB, learn how GNSS field mapping played a crucial role in creating the Port of New Orleans first enterprise GIS. Also in this issue, find out how a recent regulatory proposal could restrict UAV flights.
View More Subscribe
  • Resources
    • Construction Group
    • List rental
    • Survey And Sample
    • Associations & Industry Links
    • Subscribe
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Editorial Guidelines
    • Order Reprints
    • Want More
    • Connect
    • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise With Us
    • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe
    • My Account
    • Renew
    • Create Account
    • Change Address
    • Pay My Bill
    • Free eNewsletters
    • Customer Care

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing