Point of Beginning Blog

Pob0413_editor01_new-headshot_0311_300
Christine Grahl is the editor of POB magazine. She can be reached at 248.366.6981.

Sight Lines: Where is the Diversity?

December 16, 2008
/ Print / Reprints /
ShareMore
/ Text Size+

A reader called me last week with the question, “Why doesn’t POB highlight many women and racial minorities in its articles?” The quick and easy answer is that we are largely reflecting our audience: As evidenced by the attendees at numerous conferences and trade shows, the vast majority of individuals in the surveying profession in the U.S. are white males. While women and minorities have certainly made inroads over the past few decades, their numbers remain relatively small in comparison. But why is this so?

I suspect there are a number of reasons, all somewhat intertwined. Perhaps at the most basic level, there continues to be insufficient outreach to high school students who are evaluating various career paths. Several reports in recent years have pointed out that the number of skilled workers and college graduates entering the surveying profession is notably smaller than the number of surveyors nearing retirement. There have been some efforts on the part of surveyors, equipment dealers and educators to actively promote surveying as a profession-including a noteworthy initiative spearheaded by Delia K. Smith, PLS, in California, to establish a land surveying merit badge program in Girl Scouts modeled after a similar Boy Scouts of America program (as highlighted in the Fall 2008 issue of California Surveyor). However, more is undoubtedly needed to draw young men and women of all races into this noble profession.

Another issue is interest. For example, while I know several young women who excel in math and would probably do well in a career in an engineering-related field, none of these women is eager to spend time outdoors hauling heavy equipment over rugged terrain. Their idea of adventure is more likely to involve traipsing through cyberspace than physical space, and I would wager that this idea holds true for a number of mathematically inclined young men as well.

Interestingly, the trend toward increasing education requirements for surveying licensure might help diversify the profession simply based on statistics. According to the American Council on Education’s (ACE) Minorities in Higher Education 2008 Twenty-third Status Report, minorities outpaced whites in the percentage change in total degrees awarded at all levels over the past decade. Minority women showed stronger gains than minority men at all degree levels. Additionally, regardless of race, more women than men are earning college degrees. According to ACE, 36 percent of young men were enrolled in college in 2006 compared with 44 percent of young women. But the question of how to draw more of these young people toward a career in surveying remains.

Perhaps changes within the profession will make this question irrelevant. Related fields such as GIS and computer modeling don’t show the same disparity. As these fields become more tightly interwoven with surveying, it is likely that the tapestry of the profession will also become more diverse in race, gender and age.

These are just my thoughts. I welcome your opinions and insights on this topic, especially from women and minorities who are practicing in this field. What challenges have you encountered, and what changes do you think are needed to promote diversity in this profession? Please comment below or write to me at pobeditor@bnpmedia.com.

***************

Additional comments on this blog can be found at rpls.com.
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Diversity

Duane Frymire
December 16, 2008
Numbers for women and minorities are relatively low in all of the Professions. Professions tend to take more time and education (money) to enter than other lines of work or careers. They are also not quite as visible to young people with limited exposure to the middle or upper classes of society. So, in the case of women seeking a career, they must consider the fact that licensure might be achieved at 25-30 years old. This is the point where they can start to reap the rewards of higher pay. However, it's also the point where they may want to start a family. Very hard to do both. If they want to put off family or try both they better be getting one heck of a return. I don't think surveying is seen as giving enough of a return. In the case of minorities, the perceptions and economics have more impact. A larger percentage of minorities live in lowere incomoe neighborhoods. Having come from a low income neighborhood, I know the thinking. Many of the young people in these neighborhoods do not contemplate becoming Professionals of any sort. Nobody in the family is one, nobody they know is one. People get attracted to jobs they are familiar with because they are being done in the neighborhood or because they know someone who does them. Even if somehow a person gets interested, the education requirement is tough to fulfill, especially when you start in a position where remedial work needs to be done. Of course none of the above applies to all minorities or all women. But in general the challenges for entry to a profession are greater for a larger percentage of these groups. New York State recognizes that and does have programs to try and increase the numbers of women and minorities in the professions. The last report I saw indicates the programs are not having much of an impact.

Diversity

Richard Nagle
December 17, 2008
If somebody could get the Armed Forces interested --- more and more young women are enlisting for a few years, and maybe they are an untapped resource. Back in 1954 as a young soldier, I was sent to a 10-week "Construction Surveying" course at Ft. Belvoir, VA. I totally fell in love with this art and science. May I suggest contacting the Army Engineer Association at Ft. Leonard Wood, MO, to see if their interest could be piqued in this issue?

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

SPAR International 2013

The 10th annual event took place April 15 - 18 at The Broadmoor in Colorado Springs. The conference brings together professionals from around the world to discover the latest advances and technologies in 3D data capture, processing and delivery.

THE MAGAZINE

POB

May 2013 POB cover

May 2013

The May issue of POB features a How-To article on making technology investments pay off as well as a study conducted by BNP Media's Market Research team on salary and benefits.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Point of Beginning Store

M:\General Shared\__AEC Store Katie Z\AEC Store\Images\POB\epubsite\Statues-pic-large.gif
Surveyor Statues

The perfect gift or award for any special occasion.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications, Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

Geo Locator

Buyers Guide

The #1 buyers' guide for land surveyors and geomatics professionals. Search listings for software and equipment manufacturers, equipment dealers and professional services. CLICK HERE to view GeoLocator.

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook logo Twitter logo  LinkedIn logo  YouTube logo