Latest Headlines

URISA Board Declines to Sign Amicus Brief

March 2, 2012
/ Print / Reprints /
ShareMore
/ Text Size+

Des Plaines, Ill. - At its Feb. 24, 2012 meeting, the URISA board of directors again considered the draft Sierra Club vs. Orange County, California amicus brief. A board motion to sign an earlier version of the brief on Feb. 2 failed to pass a vote.

The board’s deliberation followed a joint URISA Board and Policy Committee conference call to discuss the board’s Feb. 2 decision, in light of the Policy’s Committee’s recommendation to sign the brief.  Glenn O’Grady, policy committee chair, was invited to again discuss the matter with the board during the Feb. 24 meeting.

After the California First Amendment Coalition won its public records act lawsuit against Santa Clara County in April 2009, the Sierra Club filed a similar suit against Orange County. The Sierra Club wanted Orange County's parcel basemap in GIS-compatible database formats for its wildlands conservation campaign but couldn't afford to pay Orange County what it was asking for the basemap. The Superior Court ruled in favor of Orange County. Sierra Club appealed the case, but the 4th District Court of Appeal affirmed the decision in support of Orange County. In response, members of the GIS community, led by Bruce Joffe, founder of the Open Data Consortium project, developed an amicus curiae brief outlining their position that GIS-formatted data is not software, and that computer mapping system software does not include GIS data.

Before considering the question of signing the SC v. OC amicus brief, the URISA board drafted and approved the following data sharing policy that reflects URISA’s role as an international organization, and the need for the organization to be aware of data policies and situations in many countries:

It is URISA's policy that all units of government should freely provide the means for their citizens to fully participate in their own governance by publishing and otherwise supplying geospatial data to all interested parties. URISA believes that governmental geospatial programs must be appropriately funded and that there are multiple acceptable mechanisms for such funding.  Credible studies have shown that the value of geospatial data to the governmental agencies and the people they serve increases with the breadth of data sharing.

The board then discussed reconsideration of signing the draft amicus brief; however, no motion to sign the brief reached the floor for a vote by the board. The board did agree to continue advocating for the principles outlined in the data sharing policy.  Specific actions will include continued pursuit of URISA’s 2011-2012 Advocacy Agenda item 2 (Nationwide Development of High Quality, Publicly Accessible Geospatial Data), participation in COGO’s URISA/NSGIC – Data Sharing Legal & Policy Framework initiative, and advocating for the newly approved URISA data sharing policy with state governors and legislatures.

“Individual URISA members are free to make their own choice to sign or not to sign the SC v. OC amicus brief,” said Greg Babinski, MA, GISP, URISA president, in a statement issued by the organization. “The value of a professional organization is not to tell its members what to think in a case like this. It is to create an environment where each individual can be exposed to the range of arguments about the issue so that they can make their own decision.  This would be the case no matter how the board voted.”

The amicus brief was submitted to the California Supreme Court on March 2 and included the signatures of 212 GIS professionals and 23 GIS organizations in support of Sierra Club.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to POB

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

HxGN Live

More than 3,500 attendees from more than 70 countries attended HxGN Live, the annual Hexagon AB user conference, at the MGM Grand Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas on June 3-6. About 450 keynotes and panel discussions were held, and several companies from around the world exhibited their geospatial products. Here are a few snapshots from the event.

9/30/14 2:00 pm EDT

Technical Workflows on the Job Site Using 3D Laser Scanning

The purpose of this webinar is to dig into different laser scanning workflows and techniques.

POB

POB September 2014

2014 September

In this September 2014 issue of POB, we take a look at a book that reveals how a rare-map dealer made millions stealing ancient maps. Also, discover the secrets of a 21st-century surveyor and how technology enables small surveying businesses to ease growing pains and maximize their potential.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Surveying Career

Would you recommend surveying as a career to a current college student?
View Results Poll Archive

Point of Beginning Store

M:\General Shared\__AEC Store Katie Z\AEC Store\Images\POB\epubsite\Statues-pic-large.gif
Surveyor Statues

The perfect gift or award for any special occasion.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications, Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

Geo Locator

Buyers Guide

The #1 buyers' guide for land surveyors and geomatics professionals. Search listings for software and equipment manufacturers, equipment dealers and professional services. CLICK HERE to view GeoLocator.

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook logo Twitter logo  LinkedIn logo  YouTube logoRPLS small logo

Google +